mix 4

here For lasting pleasance ... ... don't forget that you lot tin become all the IPKat's posts automatically yesteryear email. Just click here and the Kat volition add together you lot to the list. Have a prissy weekend.

IPKat co-blogmeister Ilanah has written an article on why the Art.6 defences may non move available inward close European Union dilution cases together with why s.10(6) may move completely off-limits inward such cases. Along the agency the article traces the origins of the honest practices proviso, takes a await at the U.S.A. concept of nominative fair purpose together with examines what the implications are for the defences amongst consider to all types of infringemt. The slice is notwithstanding inward draft form, only Ilanah would welcome comments. If you'd similar a copy, delight e-mail here .

Lipitor gives Ranbaxy heartache News of the conclusion inwards the conclusion of the Court of Appeal for England in addition to Wales inwards Ranbaxy UK Ltd v Warner-Lambert; Arrow Generics [2006] EWCA Civ 876 on 28 June has been trickling through the system, but the conclusion of Lords Justices Chadwick, Jacob in addition to Neuberger has non nonetheless been BAILII'd . constitute the summary on subscription-only service Lawtel quite helpful though. Warner Lambert was the possessor of ii patents (633 in addition to 281) for atorvastatin, a cholesterol synthesis inhibitor (better known every bit LIPITOR). Patent 633 covered ii structural formulae (I in addition to X) for an enantiomer. According to Ranbaxy it was mutual inwards organic chemical scientific discipline to purpose the structural formula of a unmarried enantiomer to announce the racemate (basically the 'left-handed' form) or 50/50 mixture of ii enantiomers of a chiral molecule. Since the racemate was to endure

The Guardian reports that Google has won a victory for its GooglePrint service inward Germany. Publisher Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft (WBG) argued that the scanning of its industrial plant infringed its copyright in addition to that this was actionable inward Germany. The spokesman from the High German printers' association (left) could non last reached for comment However, the Hamburg Regional Court’s copyright sleeping room told WBG that is application for an injunction was unlikely to succeed. Motivating this finding seems to last the fact that the scanning took house inward the US, non Germany, then U.S.A. police would apply in addition to U.S.A. police has to a greater extent than generous fair operate provisions. Because of the court’s indications, WBG withdrew its application for an injunction. is moderately surprised. He wasn’t expecting Google Print to clock upwards many copyright victories. However this wasn't an endorsement of the Google Print projection - si

Implementation delayed, implementation denied Advocate General Eleanor Sharpston QC has delivered her Opinion this forenoon inwards Case C-36/05 Commission of the European Communities v Kingdom of Spain . This is an activity brought past times the Commission against Kingdom of Spain for failing to implement Articles 1 too v of Council Directive 92/100 of xix Nov 1992 on rental too lending rights too on surely rights relating to copyright inwards the champaign of intellectual property. She advises the European Court of Justice to conclude that Kingdom of Spain is inwards the wrong. assumes that the courtroom volition obliging dominion accordingly, every bit is the normal practise when European Union fellow member states are sued for non-implementation or mis-implementation of IP Directives. Merpel agrees too says, isn't it a shame that the ECJ - which is already busy plenty - has to waste matter its fourth dimension considering whether the countries of the Union convey done what t

Onion amongst burgers enjoyed this cute exceptional in U.S. of A. of America satirical magazine The Onion about integrity-themed burger restaurants. It's a must-read for anyone who enjoys pondering issues at the interface of construct ethos together with consumerism. One of the planks on which the burger chain proposes to merchandise is that "we volition offering full, voluntary disclosure on the ingredients of all our dishes, including our world-famous hole-and-corner pancake recipe, every bit our customers accept the correct to know precisely what makes them together with thus darn fluffy". Latest IP&T The June upshot of LexisNexis Butterworths Intellectual Property together with Technology Cases has similar a shot reached the IPKat. This series, the paper-based back upwardly for the company's IP&T online subscription service, has a handsome sleek glossy dark encompass - simply it's the contents that most impress. This upshot contains reports on 7 case

Spain introduces copyright levy Slashdot reports that Kingdom of Spain is introducing a taxation on all blank media, including cd-r, dvd-r, flash media, printers, scanners in addition to mobile phones. reckons that, if a levy is beingness collected to recompense copyright holders, this should hold out reflected inward a reduced royalty flow from other forms of copyright enforcement. Prospective cost-capping inward IP cases Mann J has delivered what he states is, to his knowledge, the commencement illustration requesting a prospective cost-capping guild inward an IP case. The claimant inward this passing off activity ( Andrew Knight v Beyond ) is instructing his solicitors nether a conditional fee understanding merely does non bring afte r-the-event insurance embrace for whatsoever costs that he would bring to pay the defendants if he were unsuccessful. The defendants sought an guild which would prospectively boundary the total of costs which they would hold out liable for if the clai

asked for helpful data concerning TV programme format rights. He has directly been literally deluged amongst helpful emails from loads of readers. In the fullness of fourth dimension he volition personally admit all responses but, inwards the meantime, he says a generalised "thank you" to all who answered the call. Comments on IPKat blogs is happy to have comments on his musings, which is why he has activated the "Comments" facility at the halt of each posting. He doesn't think, though, that this facility is the correct house for people to advertise their goods together with services. This morn he deleted a comment that consisted of an promotion for a commercial production aimed at individuals who desire to file their ain U.S.A. patent applications. feels that this is an abuse of the Comment facility together with hopes that potential free-riders volition at to the lowest degree bring the courtesy to inquire earlier seeking to distribute commercial content cos

OHIM Second Board allows registration of EEC is even then recovering from the stupor of reading a recent OHIM Board of Appeal decision did non bar the term EEC – European Electronic Confidence from beingness registered every bit a score for goods as well as services inward Classes 9, 35, 36, 38 as well as 41. The determination is solely available inward French, but the IPKat has pieced it together amongst the manage of Babelfish. couldn't believe his eyes The examiner turned the score downwards every bit it conflicted amongst Art 6ter of the Paris Convention but the Board has annulled her determination as well as has remitted the representative for re-examination. The Board felt that the presence of the term European Electronic Confidence would take whatsoever possibility of confusion amongst the EEC every bit nosotros know it. Moreover, consumers would know the EEC’s purpose inward telecoms as well as the other services applied for was legislative, rather than offering such ser

A quick inquiry close formats Speaking at a conference inwards Moscow today, IPKat co-blogmeister Jeremy was asked if in that place were whatsoever skillful online resources for TV programme production companies that were interested either inwards (i) seeing what TV programme formats are available for licence too (ii) putting their ain programme formats up, then that interested licensees could contact them. If you've whatsoever useful data or ideas, delight e-mail Jeremy here . Programme formats: data from Wikipedia , Answers.com , tvformats.com too Dream Builders Big Brother Who Wants to endure a Millionaire? Countdown Survivors

NETWORK or network? The Register reports that a ring of U.K. telecom companies aren’t likewise happy. They object to the registration past times W ireless Facilities Inc of NEXT GENERATION NETWORKS. They fence that Next Generation Network is a generic term for networks which purpose digital applied scientific discipline to connect telephone calls in addition to other network traffic to a greater extent than efficiently than traditional telecoms networks. Moreover, Ofcom, the U.K. telecoms regulator has educate an manufacture grouping named Next Generation Networks U.K. to oversee the institution of such networks. wonders if this is an instance of a term which is generic amid thos e inwards the merchandise exactly isn’t familiar to the eventual consumers of such services. Coming up On Midweek – Louis Vuitton v Google inwards the Paris Court of Appeals (according to the International Herald Tribune ) On xiii July – the Advocate General’s Opinion inwards the Dyson merchandise grade ca

here How to brand H2O ice at room temperature here

New Indian GIs on the cards? According to an Indian Government press release the Indian Minister of State for Commerce is inward the procedure of identifying products for geographical indication protection to hold upwards registered amongst Geographical Indications (GI) Registry, Chennai. Amongst those existence discussed a re: *61 types of spices *Alphonso mangoes *Monsooned Malabar coffee *Nilgiris & Assam teas *Basmati rice (though talks are ongoing amongst Pakistan) *21 handicraft items says, delicious! (except for the handicraft items...) Request from an IPKat reader IPKat reader Adrian Jones asks: I'm doing around question on the police inward diverse European countries amongst catch to denigrating advertising. Would it hold upwards possible to inquire the IPKAT readers if they know of whatsoever cases inward their jurisdictions? If yous know of any, delight driblet the IPKat an electronic mail here .

here . Short introduction to French copyright constabulary here French cultural treasure (according to French Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin) here , here and here Latest BioSLR That waiflike temptress amid legal periodicals, Lawtext's fabulous as well as eccentric six-times a twelvemonth BioScience Law Review , has merely produced consequence 6 for 2004/5. The contents include Michael Blakeney's playful draw of piece of employment concern human relationship of v-GURTs which should never, good hardly ever, travel confused amongst t-GURTs (or yo-GURTS, says Merpel). Above, right: a v-GURT. NOT to travel confused amongst the t-GURT (below, left) There's too a 4 page article on the recent Great Britain House of Lords determination inwards Synthon BV v Smithkline Beecham , past times 3 authors from Freshfields whose combined names are non much shorter than the article itself. To subscribe, click here . v-GURT as well as t-GURT come upwards from www.polkadog.com

here Most recent ETMR The jumbo-sized double number of Sweet & Maxwell's European Trade Mark Reports for July-August 2006 has i time once to a greater extent than been happily published early. This number includes the next cases: * Esso plc v Greenpeace France (Cour d'appel de Paris, France) - what nosotros intend is the end of a serial of cases arising from Greenpeace's parody of the Esso merchandise score on its website; * both of the 02 v Hutchison 3G cases earlier the High Court, England as well as Wales - the curt one, where the gauge refuses to let prove explaining the results of a survey that he didn't give permission for, as well as the big one, where Mr Justice Lewison tries to larn to grips amongst an elusive bubble merchandise score comparative advertising problem, as well as the police line goes pop; * Elizabeth Emanual v Continental Shelf 128 Ltd , where the European Court of Justice affirms that a person, having sold their cry every bit a merchandise

Disney dilema The Daily Telegraph reports that Disney induce got backed downwardly inwards a dispute over Winnie the Pooh. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 dyad of grieving parents of a stillborn kid asked stonemason Aaron Clarke to include an ikon of Winnie the Pooh on the deceased child’s headstone. The parents approached Disney, who informed them that including the ikon would infringement Disney’s copyright. However, afterwards existence contacted past times reporters, Disney has right away said that it is ‘in the procedure of fulfilling their master copy request’. says that technically, Disney’s inside its rights on this one. There’s no full general exception inwards Great Britain copyright constabulary that would comprehend this situation. However, it would live on a chip hateful to halt the parents from using the ikon too it doesn’t appear correct to welcome your grapheme existence a cultural icon upwards until when its fans genuinely desire to brand reference to it, too thence

Confectionery appeals arrive at a pasty end is non surprised that, inwards Cases C-24/05 P as well as C-25/-05 P August Storck KG v OHIM , the European Court of Justice dismissed the appeals of August Storck KG against the Court of First Instance's dismissal of its appeals against the Board of Appeal's dismissal of its appeal against the examiner's thoroughly right conclusion to turn down registration of its three-dimensional marks (depicted here) equally Community merchandise marks. The Kat is horrified to come across how much fourth dimension as well as endeavour has been expended inwards demonstrating, inwards damage of audio legal logic, that these totally unmeritorious non-marks are unregistrable. These rulings are 78 as well as 89 paragraphs long, respectively. Contrast this alongside the actually of import cases: Adidas v Fitnessworld was solely 42 paragraphs long, Sabel v Puma 27 as well as fifty-fifty Windsurfing-Chiemsee (remember how endlessly long it was a

This morning’s BBC Radio four Today programme (listen here – 08.23) reported on the contestation surrounding Alan Moore too Melinda Gebbie’s Lost Girls . This graphic novel imagines a coming together betwixt Wendy (of Peter Pan), Alice (of Alice inwards Wonderland) too Dorothy of The Wizard of Oz) 1 time they convey grown up. According to the publisher’s website: "Now similar us, these 3 lost girls convey grown upwards too are cause to direct us again, this fourth dimension through the realms of our sexual awakening too fulfilment. Through their familiar fairytales they part amongst us their nearly intimate revelations of wishing inwards its many forms, revelations that polish out radiantly through the nighttime clouds of nation of war gathering to a greater extent than or less a luxury Austrian hotel. Drawing on the rich heritage of erotica, Lost Girls is the rediscovery of the ability of ecstatic writing too fine art inwards a sublime matrimony that alone the medium of comics

Easy Peasy thank you lot his friend Jim Davies for drawing his attending to the report in The Register of the abandonment past times Sir Stelios Haji-Ioannou of his activeness against Karl Kahn. The dispute arose afterward Stelios claimed that Kahn's EasyPizza.co.uk domain infringed the rights of EasyGroup (including EasyJet too other "easy" enterprises, including EasyPizza.com ) inwards the prefix "easy". Kahn, who had been trading since 1997 too registered his domain advert inwards 1999, has plainly persuaded EasyGroup to sign a consent lodge roofing his costs, estimated at £135,000, too agreeing non to interfere amongst his job concern or select whatever farther courtroom activeness without the blessing of the court. believes that many other actions brought past times the easyGroup against users of the "easy" prefix are however extant. Merpel says, I wonder how long it volition conduct maintain for the give-and-take "easy" to make such

Good intelligence for the FA that has goose egg to produce amongst Messers Rooney or Owen. At the halt of April, the FA defeated an opposition to register the ‘three lions’ shield, together amongst the words THE FA for a broad make of goods together with services. The FA applied to register a rate consisting of the England ‘three lions’ shield, amongst the words ‘The FA’ inwards a dark box inwards a higher house the shield for a broad make of goods. Henkel opposed the application inwards relation to goods inwards Classes 3 (toiletries etc), v (medicated toiletries etc) together with 21 (items related to cleaning of the trunk together with hygiene etc), based on its UK registration of the give-and-take Fa inwards the UK inwards those classes. The opposition was refused: *Henkel’s rate benefited from enhanced distinctiveness. Henkel claimed that the rate was good known inwards Europe, but the hearing officeholder works life that reputation inwards Europe was non relevant earlier the UK

referred past times the High Court inwards Oakley five Animal have been removed from the ECJ register. There's no clue every bit to why, together with it seems similar we'll move kept inwards suspense every bit to what happens if a Member State implements an optional provision out of time...

Dutch 'download' site nigh down The Dutch Court of Appeal has ordered that the Zoekmp3.nl website must endure nigh downwards according to the BBC website. Zoekmp3.nl did non host copyright-infringing music, only instead provided deep links to infringing music on other sites. The courtroom gave curt shrift to the website’s declaration that it had seat a disclaimer on the site alert p eople non to infringe copyright, saying: "Such a alert ignores the reality that the lion's part of visitors are looking for unauthorised MP3 files". The fact that Zoekmp3.nl would create goodness financially from the links because of increased traffic to the site was likewise noted. would endure mighty interested to know the precise set down on which the infringement was found. Patent Framework Document The Patent Framework Document 2006 is directly online . It’s curt only awfully racy.

The scent of copyright protection cheers Leonie Kroon , who was showtime amongst this item, every bit good every bit from Vivien Rörsch , Advocaat at De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek (this trouble solid has prepared a groovy lilliputian summary of the case, amongst comments yesteryear Tobias Cohen Jehoram ) in addition to from Piter de Weerd (www.Boek9.nl). Last Fri the Dutch Supreme Court gave judgment inwards Kecofa 5 Lancome in the dispute betwixt them over whether copyright subsists inwards a perfume. Leonie has summarised the thing every bit follows: The primal points are every bit follows: - The Dutch Copyright Act contains a non-exhaustive listing of things that tin live on a 'work' for the purposes of the act; the Supreme Court says at that spot is no argue why a odour should non live on included. - To larn copyright protection, a odour must live on a creation that is visible to humans, amongst its ‘own’ in addition to ‘original’ grapheme in addition to reflecting the per

Smokin' BusinessWire reports that the Supreme Court has refused to postulate heed an appeal past times Cubatabaco against the Second Circuit’s determination that General Cigars is entitled to ain the COHIBA merchandise score inwards the United States. The conform has been rumbling on since 1997. View the testify here . is going to refrain from making whatever com ments almost in that place beingness no smoke without fire. Patent opened upwards hearing If yous notice yourself inwards Brussels on 12 July, you’re inwards for a treat. The European Union is belongings a populace hearing on the patent system, every bit stride ii of its populace consultation on the futurity of European patent policy. Or at least, yous would hold upwards inwards for a process – despite the fact that the press release bears today’s date, registration shut on v June.

New NATO alliance? The Financial Times has exactly informed the IPKat that the U.S. too the European Union volition pledge tomorrow to accept articulation activeness to stalk the world’s swelling tide of mistaken goods. Following a tenfold ascent inwards merchandise inwards counterfeits inwards the past times vi years, the European Union too the U.S. of A. suggest to part tidings too to coordinate policy at international bodies such equally the World Intellectual Property Organisation , aiming commencement at Russian Federation too China, so at Latin America too the Middle East. EU authorities are reported to conduct keep seized to a greater extent than than 103 1000000 items of counterfeit goods inwards 2004, upwards from exactly 10 1000000 inwards 1998. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 European official adds: “The lion’s part were heading for the to the lowest degree developed countries inwards the world. This is non exactly a rich-country problem. And what nosotros seize is exactly th

SCRIPT-ed straight off online The June consequence of Edinburgh University’s SCRIPT-ed is blog has the next question: Are you lot aware of whatever courtroom cases inwards the United Kingdom of Great Britain in addition to Northern Ireland of Britain in addition to Northern Republic of Ireland that accept cited legal blogs? If so, could you lot delight permit me know, preferably amongst the representative citations in addition to the scream of the blogs? I would similar to inform my readers virtually them. If you lot know of whatever such cases, delight drib the IPKat an e-mail here in addition to he’ll frontwards it.

Pants off inwards anti-ambush marketing frenzy reads with incredulity that misfortunate megalomaniac moneygrabbing sports admininstrators FIFA ordered hundreds of Dutch fans to accept off their trousers earlier entering the stadium for their country's World Cup gibe against Republic of Cote d'Ivoire on Friday. The fans were wearing dungarees inwards the Dutch team's orangish colour, exactly bearing the logo of a Dutch beer fellowship that was non i of the World Cup official sponsors. Said FIFA: "Anyone tin article of apparel whatever they want, exactly if a fellowship tries to send out ambush marketing, FIFA must forestall that happening. In mutual alongside the IOC (International Olympic Committee) too UEFA, nosotros create non tell private supporters what to wear, exactly ... FIFA has already won a courtroom representative against a beer manufacturer who tried this classify of thing". What this agency is "Anyone tin article of apparel whatever they want, i

Bags The Poughkeepsie Journal reports that a fellowship inward the surface area has gained a U.S. of A. of America merchandise grade registration for the variety of its bag. The Healthy Back Bag already has blueprint protection, simply AmeriBag, which has sold the purse since 1995, wanted extra protection. Lynne Beresford, commissioner of trademarks at the U.S. of A. of America Patent together with Trademark Office, noted that the grant of such protection was rare because consumers don’t usually associate a product’s variety alongside a message close its origin. is never happy close the prospect of instruction consumers to stance production shapes every bit merchandise marks. If they don’t come across the production variety every bit a grade ab initio, together with then yous involve a real at nowadays message to railroad train them to create so. The mere fact that the variety has been advertised shouldn’t endure enough, without the extra message ‘look for variety X, which indicates

here ; subscribe here ; sign upward for a monthly electronic mail containing each novel issue's tabular array of contents here ; l almost frequently-read JIPLP articles here

Publishing Law has been reading the tertiary edition of Publishing Law , an easy-to-read move for non-lawyers past times Hugh Jones together with Christopher Benson. Hugh is copyright counsel to the Publishers Association in the UK, spell Christopher Benson is a solicitor amongst Anglo-German based international constabulary exercise Taylor Wessing . 's comment . This is emphatically a majority for non-lawyers who are concerned most keeping the correct side of the constabulary equally they larn most their daily activities inside the diverse sectors of the printing, publishing together with distribution industries: this way that anyone who hopes to move blinded past times legal scientific discipline or to gaze admiringly at tables of statutes, cases together with treaties volition move disappointed. The reader is instead treated to to a greater extent than or less clear, non-footnoted legal guidance, aimed at intelligent readers who volition appreciate the informed together with i