Langsung ke konten utama

Ecj Bans Merchandise Score Examiners From Slicing Their Salami


When considering the distinctiveness of a chemical compound merchandise mark, for illustration a sign made upward of letters in addition to numbers, the right approach is to pretend that y'all are the relevant consumer of the goods or services for which the applicant seeks registration of the seat in addition to and so to consider the merchandise seat equally a whole. There's zip to live gained, therefore, from "salami-slicing" the sign upward into its factor parts in addition to and so ruling that each of those parts, past times itself, is non-distinctive in addition to and so lastly that the whole seat can't live to a greater extent than distinctive than the amount of its parts. That's the moral of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling lastly Th inwards Case 329/02 SAT.1 Satellitenfernsehen GmbH v OHIM.

The applicant's seat inwards this case, SAT.2, was sought for satellite in addition to satellite broadcasting services. OHIM and the Court of First Instance (CFI) refused registration on the footing that "Sat" was curt for satellite, "2" was a issue used inwards the presentation of such services in addition to ".", beingness merely a punctuation mark, had no distinctive graphic symbol at all. The ECJ disagreed, emphasising that

* there is no presumption that elements which are individually devoid of distinctive graphic symbol cannot, on beingness combined, live perceived past times the relevant consumer equally beingness distinctive.

* there is no specific seat of linguistic or artistic inventiveness or imaginativeness that must live shown earlier a merchandise seat tin live registered. It's plenty for a seat to enable the relevant populace to set the root of the goods or services in addition to to distinguish them from those of other undertakings.

* the frequent use of merchandise marks consisting of a discussion in addition to a issue inwards the telecommunication sector showed that such a combination cannot live considered to live devoid, inwards principle, of distinctive character.

is thrilled amongst this decision, reminding readers that the CFI's judgment was vigorously criticised past times Jeremy Phillips inwards his book, Trade Mark Law: a Practical Anatomy, published lastly twelvemonth past times Oxford University Press.

More on salami here, here and here
Naughty things to produce amongst salami here, here and here
Label:

Komentar

Posting Komentar

Postingan populer dari blog ini

Australian Kazaa Case

Here’s i to sentinel out for. The Register reports on the latest phase of the Australian representative brought yesteryear Music Industry Piracy Investigations (MIPI) against Sharman Industries, the rear companionship of Kazaa. Sharman is claiming that for sure testify obtained yesteryear the MIPI from Sharman’s premises yesteryear agency of an Anton Piller order should travel declared inadmissible. It’s contention that the raids breached the Australian Telecommunications Act. It claims that MIPI took "communications" from Sharman's routers earlier they were relayed to the company's computers, reverse to the Act’s prohibition on the interception of a "communication" passing through a telecoms system. However, Judge Wilcox wasn’t impressed yesteryear this declaration in addition to fixed 29 Nov 2004 equally the trial date, though the parties volition travel going dorsum to courtroom on xvi July to written report on whether they accept sorted out their disagre
Posting Komentar
Baca selengkapnya

Where Is Canada, Anyway?

Where is Canada, anyway? Yesterday the IPKat posted an exceptional almost the Canadian Mounties' pursuit of infringers of copyright inwards karaoke inwards Canada, together amongst photograph bearing the caption "The Mounties enforcing copyright inwards Canada". He - as well as other recipients of his electronic mail circulars - thence received the next complaint from a reader, Paul Jones (Jones & Co, Bay Street, Toronto): " should reckon a refresher course of teaching inwards jurisdiction as well as geography. The Mounties bring never had whatever jurisdiction inwards Alaska, which was kickoff a Russian as well as is forthwith an American territory. Perhaps it meant to write the Yukon or the Rockies?". Resisting the temptation to audio triumphalist, the IPKat is pleased to inform his readers that Alaska is indeed inwards Canada: it is a house inwards Prince Edward Island. You tin honour it past times visiting the Natural Resources of Canada Atlas site here
Posting Komentar
Baca selengkapnya

It's The Wtmr Again

It's the WTMR again The mo number of Globe Business Publishing's bimonthly World Trademark Review has directly arrived through the IPKat-flap, amongst a giant pixellated apple tree on the front end cover. Sorry, the Kat couldn't honour a spider web page for the novel issue, or a film of the embrace to post service on this blog, together with then you'll accept to brand create amongst a dissimilar apple tree for the fourth dimension being. It's a skilful issue, though. 68 pages of seriously small-print features on topics equally varied equally * the Apple Corps/Apple Computer (non)-coexistence agreement, depending on which means you lot stance it, analysed yesteryear Herbert Smith's Joel Smith (any relation, Joel?) together with Laura Deacon; * the continuing obsession inwards the the United States amongst merchandise score dilution, yesteryear Jeffrey K. Riffer together with Brian M. Yates ( Jeffer Mangels Butler & Marmaro , Los Angeles); Left: Globe Publish
Posting Komentar
Baca selengkapnya